It is unrealistic to suggest an Eagles-listed player can take the Sandover home this year, with many of them simply not playing enough games for East Perth, and many of our bigger hopes not being midfielders.
The Sandover has been won by midfielders in nine of the past 10 seasons with Claremont key-position player Anthony Jones the lone exception in 2007, while East Perth's Ryan Turnbull (2001) was the last ruckman to claim the medal.
While we probably won’t find an overall winner, let’s take a look at the players who will get the most votes from our list.
Callum Sinclair (14 games)
Despite only playing 14 games for the season, Sinclair performed well in nearly all of them, and was utterly dominant in many. Capable of pushing forward and kicking goals, Sinclair was often the difference between winning and losing. Against Perth in round six, Sinclair racked up 20 possessions, took nine marks, had 25 hit-outs and booted two goals, including the match-winner. Against the same team in round 11, Sinclair was best afield finishing with six goals from his 21 possessions and 13 marks. Showing his versatility, Sinclair delivered a stand-out performance in atrocious conditions, gathering 23 possessions, taking four marks, working up 35 hit-outs and booting a goal. As discussed above the medal hasn’t been easy to win for key position players, but Sinclair is a safe bet to top the voting amongst the Eagles boys.
Dom Sheed (10 games)
Sheed played roughly half the season in Royals colours, thus making it virtually impossible for him to win the medal, but will still attract some love from the umpires tonight. In round three Sheed was one of the most dominant players on the field, racking up 25 disposals and booting two goals in a superb display. In round 15 against Peel Thunder, Fremantle’s aligned club, Sheed was again terrific ending the day with 25 disposals and missing the opportunity to kick bag of goals, booting 2.2 for the day. Sheed’s time in the AFL will cost him dearly, but will no doubt earn himself votes across the night.
Ash Smith (16 games)
Smith was given a change of role for season 2014 and flourished. Formerly a dashing defender, Smith was asked to play at half-forward and his run and finishing skills were a feature throughout the season. Smith averaged over 18 disposals per game at over 70% efficiency, over six marks and more than a goal per game.
Patrick McGinnity (9 games)
McGinnity has always been a fighter. Not blessed with the skill of other players, he more than makes up for it in determination and thirst for the contest. This was highlighted in round 13 where the tough on-baller had 30 possessions, five marks as well as laying seven crunching tackles. Given more freedom to win the ball at WAFL level, McGinnity could surprise a few and poll quite well.
